I've been a licensed public adjuster for over 30 years. I've handled more than a thousand claims — fires, floods, storms, you name it. And in almost every single case, the homeowner tells me the same thing: "Someone showed up at my door the day after it happened."
Contractors. "Public adjusters." Restoration companies. Roofers. They come in trucks with out-of-state plates. They hand you a business card. They tell you they can help. And they want you to sign something right now.
This is one of the biggest red flags in our industry, and I've watched it destroy people's claims — and their finances — hundreds of times. Here's what you need to know.
The Problem: Uninvited "Help" After a Loss
Within hours of a fire, flood, or major storm, people start showing up. Sometimes before the smoke has even cleared. They knock on your door, approach you in your driveway, or leave flyers on your car. They're friendly. They're sympathetic. They tell you they're "in the neighborhood helping other homeowners."
Here's the truth: they're not there to help you. They're there to help themselves.
These people — commonly known as "storm chasers" in the industry — target homeowners at their most vulnerable moment. You've just experienced a devastating loss. You're emotional, overwhelmed, and desperate for someone to tell you it's going to be okay. That's exactly what they're counting on.
"In 30+ years of handling claims, I have never — not once — seen a door-knocker who had the homeowner's best interest at heart. Not once."
How the Scam Works
These operations are more organized than you might think. Here's what happens behind the scenes:
They monitor police and fire scanners
Many storm chasers actively listen to emergency frequencies. The moment a fire or major loss is reported, they dispatch crews to the area — sometimes arriving before the insurance company even knows about the claim.
They drive through neighborhoods after storms
After a hurricane, nor'easter, or hail event, they fan out across affected neighborhoods, going door to door. They may come from out of state, set up a temporary local operation, collect as many contracts as possible, and then disappear.
They pressure you with false urgency
"You need to act now or you'll lose your claim." "The insurance company has a deadline." "If you don't sign today, I can't guarantee this price." All of this is designed to prevent you from thinking clearly, doing research, or talking to anyone else.
They offer to "waive your deductible"
This sounds like a great deal. It's actually insurance fraud — and if you go along with it, you could be held liable too. They inflate the repair costs to absorb the deductible, which is illegal and can result in your claim being denied entirely.
They get you to sign an Assignment of Benefits (AOB)
This is the big one. An AOB transfers your insurance benefits — your money — directly to the contractor. Once you sign this, they control your claim. They negotiate with your insurer on their terms, often inflating costs and creating disputes that delay your recovery for months or even years.
Someone Already Showed Up at Your Door?
Don't panic. Call us before you sign anything. We'll tell you exactly what to do — free, no obligation.
Talk to Us NowRed Flags to Watch For
After more than three decades in this business, I can tell you the warning signs are almost always the same. If any of these apply, walk away:
- They showed up uninvited. Legitimate professionals don't cruise neighborhoods looking for damaged homes. You find them — they don't find you.
- They pressure you to sign immediately. "This offer is only good today" is the oldest trick in the book. A legitimate contractor or adjuster will give you time to think.
- They offer to waive your deductible. This is insurance fraud. Period. Anyone who offers this is either ignorant of the law or deliberately trying to commit fraud — and they're dragging you into it.
- They won't give you time to research them. If someone gets nervous when you say "let me look you up online first," that tells you everything you need to know.
- They don't have proper licensing. In New York, public adjusters must be licensed by the Department of Financial Services (DFS). Contractors need proper licensing too. If they can't produce a license number on the spot, they're not legitimate.
- They ask for large upfront payments. A reputable contractor may ask for a reasonable deposit, but anyone demanding thousands of dollars before lifting a finger is a major red flag.
- They want you to sign an Assignment of Benefits. Be extremely cautious with AOBs. Once you sign one, you've given away control of your insurance claim. In most cases, there's no good reason to sign one.
How to Protect Yourself
You've just been through something terrible. The last thing you need is to get taken advantage of. Here's exactly what I tell every homeowner I work with:
1. Never sign anything on the spot
I don't care how good the deal sounds. I don't care how nice the person is. If someone shows up at your door with a contract, the answer is always: "Let me think about it." A legitimate professional will respect that. A scammer won't.
2. Ask for their license number and verify it
In New York, you can verify a public adjuster's license through the NY Department of Financial Services (DFS). If they claim to be a licensed contractor, verify that too. If they can't give you a license number, end the conversation.
3. Get multiple estimates
Never go with the first contractor who shows up. Get at least three written estimates from licensed professionals you've vetted yourself. Compare scope of work, not just price.
4. Check BBB, Google reviews, and references
Look them up. Read the reviews. Check the Better Business Bureau. Ask for references from past clients. A company with a real track record will have a real online presence.
5. Take your time
This is the most important thing I can tell you: legitimate professionals will wait. Your insurance claim doesn't expire overnight. You have time to make an informed decision. Anyone who tells you otherwise is trying to manipulate you.
6. Contact your insurance company before hiring anyone
Report your claim first. Understand what your policy covers. Then make decisions about who to hire. Don't let a stranger at your door dictate the timeline.
7. Consider hiring a licensed public adjuster who works for YOU
Unlike the insurance company's adjuster (who works for them), a public adjuster is a licensed professional who works exclusively for you, the policyholder. We handle the entire claims process, negotiate with your insurer, and fight for the maximum settlement you're entitled to.
Need a Licensed Professional on Your Side?
We work for you — not the insurance company. Free consultation, no obligation, and we only get paid when you do.
Talk to Us NowLegitimate Public Adjuster vs. Scammer: Know the Difference
Not everyone who offers to help with your claim is a scammer. There are honest, licensed professionals who do this work every day. Here's how to tell the difference:
A legitimate public adjuster:
- Is licensed by the state — in New York, through the Department of Financial Services
- Works on a contingency basis — you don't pay unless they get you paid
- Doesn't pressure you — they'll answer your questions, give you time, and let you decide
- Has a verifiable track record — real reviews, real references, real history in the community
- Works for you, the policyholder — not for the insurance company, not for a contractor, not for themselves
- Will never ask you to sign an AOB — because they don't need to. They work alongside you, not in place of you
A scammer:
- Shows up uninvited at your property
- Pressures you to sign immediately
- Can't produce valid licensing
- Offers deals that sound too good to be true (like waiving your deductible)
- Gets defensive or evasive when you ask questions
- Wants control of your claim through an Assignment of Benefits
- Has no online presence, no reviews, and no verifiable references
What to Do If You've Already Been Scammed
If you've already signed something with a door-knocker, don't panic. There are steps you can take right now:
1. Contact the NY Department of Financial Services (DFS)
File a complaint at dfs.ny.gov or call their consumer helpline. They investigate unlicensed and fraudulent insurance activity and can take action against the person or company.
2. File a police report
If someone misrepresented themselves, pressured you into signing under false pretenses, or took money without delivering services, this is a criminal matter. File a report with your local police department.
3. Contact your insurance company immediately
Let your insurer know what happened. If you signed an AOB, they need to know. In many cases, your insurer can help you navigate the situation and may be able to work with you to regain control of your claim.
4. Get legal help
If you signed a contract under duress or based on fraudulent misrepresentation, an attorney may be able to help you void that contract. Many consumer protection attorneys offer free consultations.
5. Call a licensed public adjuster
Even if things have gone sideways, it's not too late. A licensed public adjuster can review your situation, help you understand your options, and work to get your claim back on track.
"I've had clients come to me after signing with a storm chaser, and we were still able to help. It's harder, it takes longer, but it's not hopeless. The sooner you reach out, the better."